Matte Black vs Brushed Gold: Honest Notes From Six Bathrooms

Matte Black vs Brushed Gold: Honest Notes From Six Bathrooms

Every client asks the same question: "Matte black, or brushed gold?" The honest answer is that it depends on the room, but there are patterns. We have done three bathrooms this year in each finish. Here is what actually held up, what showed fingerprints, and what the cleaner said about both.

Vanity with mirror detail

Lindfield: close-up of the vanity-mirror-basin triangle where finish shows the most.

Matte black: the bold, the practical, and the smudgy

Matte black looks fantastic in photos. In real life it shows every water drop, every finger smear, and every bit of toothpaste. If your household has small children or a long-haired dog, factor in a weekly wipe-down. For everyone else it is probably fine.

Celine Twin Shower Combo Matte Black
Otti
Celine Twin Shower Combo Matte Black
$630
Vetto Shower Head Stainless Steel Round  250mm Matte Black
Otti
Vetto Shower Head Stainless Steel Round 250mm Matte Black
$150
Cora 36 Counter-Top Fluted Round Basin- Matt Black
Mercio
Cora 36 Counter-Top Fluted Round Basin- Matt Black
$346
Marsay 73S Wall-Hung Rectangular Basin - Matt Black
Mercio
Marsay 73S Wall-Hung Rectangular Basin - Matt Black
$287

What works with matte black: warm timber vanities, white stone, soft-grey grout. What fights with it: cool-grey tiles and anything chrome. Pick a lane.

Brushed gold: the one that reads as expensive

Brushed gold hides water spots almost completely. The texture of the brushing scatters light and camouflages everything a matte finish would show. It also lasts longer in beachside bathrooms because the finish is more forgiving when salt air gets to it.

Vetto Shower Head Stainless Steel Round  250mm Argent Gold
Otti
Vetto Shower Head Stainless Steel Round 250mm Argent Gold
$248
Aluminum Framed 900mm Round Mirror - Matt Black
Mercio
Aluminum Framed 900mm Round Mirror - Matt Black
$396
Aluminum Framed 900mm Rectangular Mirror - Matt Black
Mercio
Aluminum Framed 900mm Rectangular Mirror - Matt Black
$326

Match the accessories or do not bother

Mixed metals almost never look intentional in a small bathroom. Pick one, then buy the matching accessories at the same time so you are not hunting for the exact shade of brushed gold in six months.

GLOBE Series Tumbler Holder – Matt Chrome
Mercio
GLOBE Series Tumbler Holder – Matt Chrome
$42
ZEN Series Tumbler Holder – Matt Chrome
Mercio
ZEN Series Tumbler Holder – Matt Chrome
$42
FLAT Series Toilet Brush Holder – Matt Black
Mercio
FLAT Series Toilet Brush Holder – Matt Black
$42
Our rule of thumb: matte black for apartments and inner-city houses. Brushed gold for family homes and anything near the beach. Chrome when you want it to disappear, which is more often than people think.
Back to blog